November 19, 2026
The brick house at 24620 Deer Trace Drive went up in 1988, in the part of Marsh Landing that St. Johns County records as Marsh Landing at Sawgrass Unit Three. One family bought it in January 2000 for $579,000 and kept it for more than 25 years. On July 1, 2025, they sold it for $900,000. Fifteen months later, on October 5, 2026, the house sold again for $2,550,000. The Jax Daily Record's weekly list of top Northeast Florida home sales for recordings made October 5 through 11, 2026, carried the sale on a 0.8-acre lot, along with the $900,000 price it last brought in 2025.
When the house came back to market, its listing described it as completely renovated. The public record does not say what was done between the two sales or what the work cost. A price that nearly tripled on the same house and the same lot in 15 months points to substantial work, and the appraiser now counts 3,762 square feet of conditioned space there.
That one house explains how Marsh Landing prices homes better than any community-wide median can. Inside this gate, a house's recent history and the land under it move the price. The year it was built and the name on the entry sign move it much less.
Twenty-five days after the Deer Trace closing, a house of nearly the same size sold on Green Heron Way, in Marsh Landing at Sawgrass Unit Twenty-Eight. The St. Johns County Property Appraiser lists it as built in 2000 with 3,690 square feet of conditioned space. It sold on October 30, 2026, for $1,550,000. Its listing described golf-course views and a new roof.
That comes to about $420 per square foot on Green Heron Way and about $678 per square foot on Deer Trace Drive. The house that is 12 years older sold for roughly $1 million more.
Here are the four Marsh Landing sales that closed between August and October 2026, using the appraiser's conditioned square footage:
| Address | Year built | Conditioned sq ft | Sale date | Sale price | Approx. price per sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 193 Admirals Way S | 2016 | 6,710 | Aug. 14, 2026 | $6,700,000 | $998 |
| 467 Royal Tern Road S | 2003 | 6,130 | Sept. 15, 2026 | $3,970,000 | $648 |
| 24620 Deer Trace Drive | 1988 | 3,762 | Oct. 5, 2026 | $2,550,000 | $678 |
| Green Heron Way | 2000 | 3,690 | Oct. 30, 2026 | $1,550,000 | $420 |
The oldest house in the table does not have the lowest price per square foot. The 1988 home sold for more per square foot than the 2003 estate on Royal Tern Road and far more than the 2000 house on Green Heron Way. If you sort Marsh Landing by year built, you get a ranking that this fall's buyers did not follow.
The Green Heron Way record card shows how a Marsh Landing house appreciates over a long stretch without a quick resale. The lot sold vacant in July 1999 for $134,400. The finished house sold for $630,000 in December 2000, for $645,000 in 2003, and for $820,000 in November 2004. A relocation company bought and resold it on the same day in December 2007, at $780,000 and then $730,000. The next sale at market price came in October 2026, at $1,550,000.
Measured from the 2004 sale, the house gained about 89 percent over 22 years. The Deer Trace house gained about 55 percent over its 25-year hold, from $579,000 in 2000 to $900,000 in 2025. Then it gained another $1.65 million in the 15 months between its last two sales, more than five times what the previous 25 years had added.
Those two records put numbers on something a buyer can price. Time alone moved both houses at a steady pace. The jump on Deer Trace came after a change of hands and a listing that called the home completely renovated, and this fall about $1 million separated two homes of about 3,700 square feet in the same community.
Recent work explains the middle of the market. At the top, the lot carries the price, and the Admirals Way record card shows how land along the Intracoastal side of the community has repriced.
The parcel at 193 Admirals Way S sits in the Harbour at Marsh Landing Unit One. It changed hands as vacant land five times before anyone built on it. The prices were $572,700 in 1996, $645,000 in 1998, $750,000 in 1999, $1,750,000 in February 2007, and $1,250,000 in November 2012. The 2012 buyer built a 6,710-square-foot house, which the appraiser dates to 2016. It sold on August 14, 2026, for $6,700,000, just under $1,000 per square foot. Its listing noted direct Intracoastal frontage.
The Royal Tern Road sale falls between the two extremes. The house at 467 Royal Tern Road S, in the Marsh Landing at Sawgrass Unit 32A neighborhood, was built in 2003 and sits on 3.14 acres. It sold for $2,925,000 in September 2023 and for $3,970,000 on September 15, 2026, a gain of about 36 percent in three years. The Jax Daily Record included it among the top Northeast Florida sales recorded September 14 through 20, 2026. Its listing described Intracoastal and marsh views. At about $648 per square foot, it sold for less per square foot than the Deer Trace house. Royal Tern has about 2,400 more square feet of house, and price per square foot usually comes down as a house gets larger. A big estate on more than three acres is priced mostly on its land and its views, while a mid-size house is priced mostly on how it shows.
Land near the water carries a high floor in Marsh Landing, and the Admirals Way deeds show that floor rising over three decades. Away from the water, recent work did more than age or acreage to decide where a house landed this fall.
For context, Northeast Florida Realtors reported a single-family median of $564,449 for all of St. Johns County in October 2026, with 391 closed sales, a median of 49 days on market, and 3.8 months of supply. The lowest of these four Marsh Landing sales closed at almost three times that county figure, so the county number says little about what a home inside this gate costs.
A Marsh Landing-wide median has the same problem on a smaller scale. A community median moves with which houses happened to sell, so a quarter heavy on recently renovated mid-size homes and waterfront estates looks like a rising market, and a quarter with fewer of them looks like a falling one, even if no house changed value. We saw the same effect in Sawgrass Players Club's falling median, where a small sample made the trend look bigger than it was. In Marsh Landing the mix matters even more, because this fall about 3,700 square feet traded at $420 per square foot in one sale and $678 in another.
If you are comparing Marsh Landing with other Ponte Vedra golf communities, an older house here is not automatically the cheaper option. The 1988 Deer Trace home sold for more than a 2000 home of the same size. When you compare listings, match them on recent work and on lot first, then on size, and only after that on age.
A buyer weighing a home that has not been updated is pricing the house plus the money and months it would take to update it. The Deer Trace deeds show how far apart those two prices can sit in this community, $900,000 and $2,550,000 for the same house on the same lot, 15 months apart. A seller of a home that has not been updated faces the same choice from the other side, selling as is to the buyer who will do the work or doing the work first. Our guide to preparing an older Ponte Vedra home for market covers how presentation fits into that decision. Our Marsh Landing community page and our earlier comparison of Marsh Landing and Sawgrass Players Club cover the setting and the golf.
Budget for the club as a separate line. Marsh Landing Country Club's membership page lists full golf, junior, sports and social categories. It says memberships carry a one-time nonrefundable initiation fee plus monthly dues, but it does not publish the amounts. Get current figures from the club before you set a price ceiling for the house.
If you own an older home in Marsh Landing and want to know where it falls between this fall's $420 and $678 per square foot, The Morrow Group will build that comparison from the county's recorded sales, matched to your lot and your home's recent work. Request a Complimentary Home Valuation, and we will show you what updating would likely add and what selling as is would likely bring.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
November 19, 2026
November 12, 2026
November 5, 2026
October 29, 2026
October 22, 2026
October 15, 2026
October 8, 2026
October 1, 2026
September 24, 2026
Are you interested in buying or selling a home? Look no further than working with our real estate experts. We pride ourselves on providing personalized solutions that bring our clients closer to their dream properties and enhance their long-term wealth. Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!